Thursday, September 23, 2010

Red Dead Redemption (Soon to be followed by about 4 new reviews)

So, Red Dead Redemption. To state the obvious, this is a western shooter. It has duels, vendettas, guys with clearly evil mustaches, and even a train robbery or two. What you might be confused about is what the hell Rockstar, the company famous for its Grand Theft Auto games, is doing trying to make a western shooter. Wait, they did! This is a sequel to their earlier game, Red Dead Revolver. To refresh my memory, I revisited the plot of Revolver and made sure that I hadn't just forgotten the story of the old game, which, it seemed, with the way they dragged the backstory on and on, would have explained everything, but nooooooooooooooo! This is actually a fresh plot and they've introduced a few new game aspects, some of which are completely unnecessary.
Let's start with the combat. The combat is fun. The cover-based shooting mechanic works pretty well, since the designers managed to remember that you can use rocks, gates, and even trees as cover. Thus, you can always find cover, but why would you want to when you have a "murder everyone" combat feature? Their addition to cover-based combat is the addition of "dead-eye", the ability to basically stop time for 10 seconds, during which you can line up all your shots and murder anything that isn't hiding behind a rock. This makes most of the combat laughably easy to do, but the real kicker is that you really don't need it! Your health regenerates, making it not as important to line up your shots perfectly, and most of the difficult missions (you know, the ones where you are sitting behind a gatling gun and have to eat up enemy fire while they get to hide behind rocks) don't even LET you use dead-eye. Thus, dead-eye is unnecessary. I went through half the levels forgetting I even had it. It's like turning the cheats on, especially if you buy moonshine for a mere 30 bucks, which gives you unlimited dead-eye for about 10 seconds, making it 20 seconds of murder. I never actually used that item, though, because you lock on to enemies automatically in normal combat (assuming you're pointed in their general direction).
Oh, yes, and the minigames. I hated most of them. They're extraordinarily difficult to win money in, first off, and some of them are just frustratingly difficult to do, especially the horseshoes minigame. It takes forever, and there is no targeting cursor or anything to help you aim. What isn't frustratingly difficult is also probably mind-numbingly boring, as going on "ranch patrol" for 20 bucks just makes you want to be proactive by, say, killing the bandits before they get to the ranch.
The biggest gripe I have about the game is that the crime system doesn't really know what it wants to be in the game. While Rockstar added an "honor" bar, which is a reincarnation of the good/evil meter we've seen since the dark ages of gaming, it doesn't have much bearing on what you do. Most of the rewards for being a good citizen involve giving you the ability to commit more crimes. While I don't know what the negative honor side gives, if it doesn't make crime pay better, I wouldn't see much of a point to it. Most of the clear moral choices have really no benefit to choosing the less moral option, and the normal robbing and murdering usually just causes too many problems to bother. Robbing people gives you a terribly small amount of money, which might be useful early in the game, but at that point in time they haven't really even introduced you to the crime system, so it's pretty useless. Also, if you're a nice guy, but really need to kill someone (or want to), you can just put on a bandana and poof! No more honor or fame changes. They'll still arrest you, though. And since robbery and murder is mostly just done to get more fame and less honor (since, as I've said before, crime doesn't pay), there really isn't a reason to use the bandana unless you want a quick little crime spree, which you'll probably have to end up paying a fine for, anyways.
Regardless, the plot seems like it should be the 2nd part of a story, and would have made a great game... probably. The game has a near-insane ability to make you waste time with the minigames, but to their credit, some of them are done well, as I admittedly spent hours playing the poker and Liar's Dice minigames and eventually decided that 3:30AM was kinda late to keep playing. The best fun I had was the story missions, as would be expected, but I definitely appreciated the ability to just wander off into new areas with no particular goal in mind and find something to do. On the road, I had so many things happen to me that I became convinced that they took longer to program than all of the story missions. Even if you don't have random encounters with bandits, there are plenty of strangers strewn about the landscape who have something random for you to do. On top of that, there are challenges for gathering herbs, as well as some ridiculous hunting challenges, such as shooting birds in midair and killing wolves with a knife.
I rented this game, and I beat it with about 2 days to go, but admittedly I played a lot. There are far too many story missions to worry about reaching the end of the game even when you think you're close. There were about 10 times where I was convinced the game was ending soon, and there was even a actual terrible, terrible fake ending that I won't spoil. Just remember to keep playing after the "end", as you might see it. Strangers are helpful. You'll know the REAL end when you see it.

tl;dr
RDR is a great game.
It's filled with fun things to do that take up a LOT of time.
Buying this game is a good idea because you can play it forever.
You can hogtie people.
I hate bears.

No comments:

Post a Comment